By Estes Davis Law | Baton Rouge, Louisiana
If you drive, haul, build, or do labor for a company that pays you on a 1099, you may have been told you are “not an employee,” so you have no workers’ comp if you get hurt. A Louisiana appeals court ruling from early October 2026 is a good reminder that this is not always true.
In Louisiana, whether you are covered by workers’ compensation depends on how the work actually happens, especially who controls it, and not just on the tax form you were given.
In Smith v. RNK Construction, L.L.C., No. 2026-CA-0078 (La. App. 4 Cir. Oct. 2, 2026), a dump-truck driver was hurt in December 2022 when his truck hit a protective barrier on Louisiana Highway 1 on the way back from a sand delivery to Grand Isle. The company denied his medical care and wage benefits, arguing he was an independent contractor. A workers’ compensation judge agreed and denied the claim.
In a 3–2 decision, the Louisiana Fourth Circuit Court of Appeal reversed. According to the court, the company:
The company pointed out that the driver received a 1099, paid his own taxes, and got no employee benefits. The court found those facts did not outweigh the company’s control over his work. Applying the long-standing control factors from the Louisiana Supreme Court’s Hickman decision, it held the company had not overcome the legal presumption that he was an employee, and it sent the case back to decide what benefits he is owed. Two judges dissented, and the case may not be over, but the reasoning is worth knowing.
Louisiana’s workers’ compensation law starts from a presumption that favors workers. Under La. R.S. 23:1044, a person who performs services for another in a covered trade or business is presumed to be an employee. The company claiming you are a contractor has to prove it.
Courts look at the real relationship, not the label. Common questions include:
No single factor decides every case. A 1099, a signed “independent contractor agreement,” or paying your own taxes can be considered, but as this case shows, they can be outweighed by how much control the company really had.
Even a true independent contractor may be covered. Louisiana law says an independent contractor who spends a substantial part of their work time doing manual labor under the contract is covered by workers’ comp (La. R.S. 23:1021(7)). This can matter for many trades and laborers.
There is an important limit: the same law says operating a truck tractor or truck-tractor trailer, including driving, fueling, hooking and unhooking trailers, and inspections, is not “manual labor.” So 18-wheeler drivers usually cannot rely on this rule and must show they are actually employees. In the Smith case, though, the court held that this truck-tractor language does not cover dump trucks, and that it does not mean a dump-truck driver must be treated as an independent contractor. Every situation depends on its own facts.
Being labeled a contractor when you are really an employee can affect more than workers’ comp. Under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act, employees generally must be paid at least minimum wage and time-and-a-half for hours over 40 in a week. Contractors are not. Federal wage law uses its own test, which is different from Louisiana’s comp test, but if a company controls your work like an employer, it is worth asking whether you have been shorted on pay as well.
Louisiana comp claims have short time limits. In general, a claim for wage benefits must be filed within one year of the accident, or within one year of the last benefit payment if payments were made. Claims for medical benefits generally must be filed within one year of the accident, or within three years of the last medical payment (La. R.S. 23:1209). There are special rules for injuries that show up later. Waiting to sort out whether you are an “employee” can cost you your claim, so it is wise to get answers early.
If you were hurt on the job and were told you can’t get workers’ comp because you’re a “contractor,” you can contact Estes Davis Law for a free consultation to have your situation reviewed. Every case depends on its own facts, and no lawyer can promise a particular result.
This post is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome in any future case.