By Randy Estes, August 12, 2026
An accusation of fraud is one of the most frightening things that can happen in a workers’ compensation claim. Under Louisiana law, a worker who makes a willful false statement to obtain benefits can lose those benefits entirely. For years, injured workers faced an added fear: that a single misstatement could wipe out everything, all the way back to the date of the injury — including benefits they had legitimately earned. On June 29, 2026, the Louisiana Supreme Court settled that question, and the answer offers real protection for injured workers.
Louisiana Revised Statute 23:1208 says that any employee who willfully makes a false statement or representation for the purpose of obtaining workers’ compensation benefits forfeits the right to those benefits. This is a serious rule, and it applies to both sides — employers and insurers can be penalized for false statements too. It exists to protect the integrity of the system, and it is not to be taken lightly.
The hard question was not whether forfeiture applies. It was how far back it reaches.
Imagine a worker who is genuinely hurt on the job, receives benefits for several weeks, and then — months later — says something false during a deposition. Does the fraud cancel only the benefits going forward from the false statement? Or does it erase every dollar paid since the injury, even the benefits the worker legitimately earned before the lie was ever told?
Louisiana’s appellate courts had split on this for more than two decades. One line of cases held that forfeiture runs forward, starting from the date of the false statement. Another allowed forfeiture to reach all the way back to the injury. Workers in different parts of the state were being treated differently depending on which court heard their case.
In Cousain v. Smitty’s Supply, Inc., No. 2025-C-01318 (La. 6/29/26), the Louisiana Supreme Court resolved the split. The Court held that forfeiture under Section 1208 runs forward — it cancels benefits from the date of the false statement onward, but it does not erase benefits the worker legitimately earned before that point.
The case grew out of a 2021 work-related car accident. The employee later gave deposition testimony about an emergency-room visit that medical records showed had not happened as he described it. A workers’ compensation judge found that he had willfully made a false statement to obtain benefits and cut off his benefits from the date of that deposition forward, along with a $1,000 fine. But the roughly twelve weeks of disability benefits he had legitimately earned before the false statement were not taken away.
Reading the statute’s forfeiture and restitution provisions together, the Supreme Court concluded that the law lets an insurer recover benefits that were fraudulently obtained up to the point the fraud is discovered — but it does not reach backward to strip away benefits a worker rightfully earned before any misrepresentation. The Court adopted the “forward-only” approach and overruled the conflicting line of cases. Louisiana now has one clear, statewide rule.
It is worth noting that in the same case, the employer was penalized for its own conduct — for failing to timely pay indemnity benefits, failing to authorize medical care, and failing to honor the employee’s choice of physician. Section 1208 and the surrounding penalty provisions are not a one-way street. Just as workers can be penalized for dishonesty, employers and insurers can be penalized for wrongly denying or delaying legitimate benefits.
The most important takeaway is not that dishonesty is now safe — it is not. A Section 1208 violation still ends benefits going forward and can bring fines. Honesty and accuracy in every form, statement, and deposition remain absolutely essential to protecting your claim.
What the ruling does is put a limit on the damage. If you were genuinely injured and legitimately received benefits, a later dispute over something you said should not, by itself, allow the insurer to claw back everything from day one. That protects workers from having an honest injury claim erased over a single contested statement.
It also underscores why representation matters. Insurers sometimes raise fraud allegations aggressively, and small inconsistencies — confused dates, imperfect memories of medical visits — can be portrayed as intentional lies. An experienced attorney can help you respond to a fraud allegation, protect the benefits you have rightfully earned, and hold the insurer accountable if it has wrongly denied your care.
If you have been hurt on the job — or if an insurer is accusing you of fraud — do not try to navigate it alone. At Estes Davis Law, we help injured Louisiana workers protect their benefits and their futures. Call us at (225) 336-3394 for a free, confidential consultation. Se habla español.
This article is general information about Louisiana law and is not legal advice. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome; every case depends on its own facts. For advice about your situation, please consult an attorney.
About the Author